Sports Card Memories

What life was like before computers and video games...

Player of the Week ~ Home

1989 Donruss Curt Schilling Rookie Card

Posted on April 8, 2012 at 5:00 PM

 


I could go on and on about Curt Schilling, some good, some bad. So take a seat and get ready. This post will be like nothing you have read from me. Here we go...


Schilling came to the Orioles in a trade with Boston for Mike Boddicker. I was going to school at Towson State in Maryland when the trade went down. I chuckled because Boddicker was a solid pitcher and neither Schilling nor Brady Anderson, the other player in the deal, showed much when they came to the Orioles.


I saw him pitch in 1988. I believe it was against the Angels, but don't shoot me if I am wrong. It might have been a doubleheader, again, I'm not sure. Anyway, they shelled him and from that day forward, I always knew him as Curt Schelling. Yeah, I was young...


Then the Orioles traded him along with Pete Harnisch and Steve Finley for Glenn Davis, who was an Astros power hitter and a stud. I couldn't believe the Orioles of all organizations could steal a player like Davis for three scrubs. Little did I know that Davis would get injured over and over and barely play for the Orioles before retiring. Davis was on the DL, sitting in the dugout, and a line drive shattered his jaw. Sometimes, you just can't win.


So he kicked around with the Astros briefly before being traded to the Phillies for  Jason Grimsley in one of those, I'll take your junk if you take ours deals. Who knew?? Not Houston. The rest is history to baseball fans but I'll tell you this, it didn't seem Schilling had that many fans in the Phillies dugout. The towel over the head while Mitch Williams pitched probably didn't do him any favors.


Let's move forward to retirement. Schilling is out of baseball and must wait five years to be eligible for the Hall of Fame. Upfront, I am not a supporter of his candidacy. He belongs in the Hall of Very Good, but not the Hall of Fame. But let's just say somehow he gets the votes to get in. He was with the Red Sox and that helps, and he has two rings and a bloody sock so anything can happen.


What hat does he wear on his Hall of Fame plaque? If you ask him, I'm certain he'll say Red Sox. Sorry Curt, it ain't gonna happen! The Hall of Fame decides which hat you will wear on your plaque thanks to players like Davie Winfield who actually attempted to sell his plaque to the highest bidder. When Gary Carter was elected, he begged and pleaded to wear a Mets' cap. They wouldn't let him. Carter spent 11 seasons with the Expos (his plaque) and only five with the Mets. Even with his World Series ring, they refused to let him in with a Mets' cap.


As for Schilling, he spent eight seasons in Philly and only four with the Red Sox. How could the Hall of Fame justify letting him in with a Red Sox cap after denying Carter his choice? Could they say "bloody sock" and "2 rings?" Anything is possible and none of us have a say in the matter, but with Carter passing recently, I would hope they would not dishonor him that way.


I think this is all for nothing as Schilling in no way a Hall of Famer. But I find it an interesting topic of conversation. I would love to hear what you have to say about it.

Categories: Memory of the Week

Post a Comment

Oops!

Oops, you forgot something.

Oops!

The words you entered did not match the given text. Please try again.

Already a member? Sign In

8 Comments

Reply Patrick McCrystal
05:28 PM on January 29, 2013 
That moustache makes him look like one of the guys from "To Catch A Predator"!
Reply swamilee@comcast.net
11:45 PM on January 18, 2013 
According to MLB, where he played his best baseball is not a deciding factor. Just ask Gary Carter's family.
Reply Michael Katz
04:47 PM on January 04, 2013 
Where did Schilling play his best baseball? I'd have to say Arizona. Shouldn't that be the deciding factor? I'd have to say it should, but upon further reflection I hope it never matters, because I have fallen off the fence and decided that Curt is not HoF-worthy.
Reply swamilee@comcast.net
10:04 PM on June 12, 2012 
Fart says...
"Schilling in no way a Hall of Famer. " How about you back this up with facts. Don't cherry pick either - INclude his 3,116 strikeouts and 11-2/2.23 postseason record.

Go ahead, I'm waiting.


The point of this entry wasn't Schilling being or not being a HOFer, though I again say I'm not in support of him. He played too long with way too few wins for some very good teams. He was "Very Good" but he was not a legend aside from the "Bloody Sock."
My point was, which cap would he wear if he was enshrined. Though I'll tell you this, I'm just happy somebody is reading so please feel free to question any and all that I write. And I will be adding to this site again soon and more consistently.
So thanks for reading!
But I will say this, a player does not get to Cooperstown on post-season success only or half the New York Yankees of the past 20 years would be enshrined...then again, as screwed up as things are, maybe they will.
Reply Fart
09:55 PM on June 12, 2012 
"Schilling in no way a Hall of Famer. " How about you back this up with facts. Don't cherry pick either - INclude his 3,116 strikeouts and 11-2/2.23 postseason record.

Go ahead, I'm waiting.
Reply Michael Katz
03:23 PM on April 20, 2012 
Don't forget that ring he got in Arizona, which makes three. You might say that his career was a three-ring circus?

Seriously, I am on the fence about Schilling for one simple reason - Jack Morris. I say Jack belongs in the HOF, largely on the strenth of being "money" when it mattered most. Schilling's numbers are not much worse than Jack's numbers, and like Jack's profile it is boosted by being clutch when it mattered most.
Reply swamilee@comcast.net
09:36 PM on April 08, 2012 
There is no doubt in my mind Schilling was a money pitcher. Can't argue that at all. Some will say he is a HOFer because of that, but I don't think it's enough. Sad that the Phillies got pretty much nothing for him when they traded him to Arizona.

karch says...
my fav Schilling memory is when the Tribe was considering trading Thome (before he when to Philly via free agency) for him. I told my buddy who was a die hard Tribe fan that they needed to make the trade. The Tribe had plenty of offense (Manny, Martinez, Lofton, eltal) but were a top pitcher away from winning it all. Say what you will about Curt (self promoting, etc) but for a money game pitcher from 2000-2006 he was top 1-2 in baseball. But HOF material?, no frigging way...
Reply karch
08:34 PM on April 08, 2012 
my fav Schilling memory is when the Tribe was considering trading Thome (before he when to Philly via free agency) for him. I told my buddy who was a die hard Tribe fan that they needed to make the trade. The Tribe had plenty of offense (Manny, Martinez, Lofton, eltal) but were a top pitcher away from winning it all. Say what you will about Curt (self promoting, etc) but for a money game pitcher from 2000-2006 he was top 1-2 in baseball. But HOF material?, no frigging way...